A building materials website should help a buyer do five things without calling you first. They should be able to tell if you sell to them, find the product, see proof that fits their job, reach the right place or person, and ask for help. You can test all five in under an hour with a phone and one person who did not build the site.
Hand that person the phone. Give them a real job to do. Then watch where they stop.
Do not explain the menu while they use it. If you have to stand next to the site to make it work, you found something worth fixing.
How to Set Up the Test
Pick a tester who looks like a real buyer. A newer person at the counter can work. So can a friend who builds or remodels. Your web person and your sales manager are the worst picks, because they already know where everything is.
Write one made-up job on a card. For example: "You are a contractor. You need an exterior door for a customer in this town. Find out if this company can help, and ask for a quote." Do not use a real customer's plans or name.
Use a phone for the test. That is how a contractor in a truck or on a jobsite would see your site.
Test 1: Can the Buyer Tell If You Sell to Them?
Ask the tester who this company sells to and where it works.
A manufacturer, a two-step distributor, and a local dealer can carry the same kind of product and serve very different buyers. A homeowner should not have to fill out a trade account form to learn that you only sell through dealers.
- Pass: the tester can say who you serve and what to do next without guessing.
- Fix first: put who you sell to and where you work near the top. If buyers need a dealer, say so and show them how to find one.
Test 2: Can They Find the Product and Its Limits?
Ask the tester to find one product your team wants to sell more of. Then ask where they would check sizes, options, and the current spec sheet.
A photo gallery can show what is possible without showing what you supply. A good product page makes that clear.
- Pass: the tester can name the product or line and find the right place to check the details.
- Fix first: label the line, link the current documents, and remove claims your team cannot back up.
Do not grade whether the tester picked the right product for a job. That still takes someone qualified. If product pages keep failing here, see what belongs on a building product page.
Test 3: Can They Find Proof That Fits Their Job?
Ask for one project, product demo, or plain explanation that helps with the job on the card. A wall of logos does not count.
Say a custom millwork buyer lands on your site. Useful proof might show the kind of detail your shop can make and who to ask about a new drawing. It should not suggest that every photo is a standard item.
- Pass: the tester can say what the proof shows and what still needs a conversation.
- Fix first: add captions that say what the buyer is looking at, plus a next step. Get the customer's OK before you use their project as proof.
Test 4: Can They Reach the Right Place or Person?
Use the path that fits how you sell. That might be visiting a showroom, finding a dealer, calling a branch, or reaching a rep.
- Pass: the place or person is the right one, the contact details are current, and the buyer knows what happens next.
- Fix first: remove dead ends. If you send someone to another company, say why. If a showroom needs an appointment, say so before they drive over.
Where you show up on a map is a separate check. Here you only want to know if a buyer who reached your site can use it.
Test 5: Can They Ask for Help Without Starting Over?
Have the tester walk through your quote or contact form up to the send button. Then stop. Do not send a fake lead to your sales team.
Watch for these things. Does the form keep the product they were looking at? Does it say which details your team needs? Does it work on a phone? Does it say what happens after they send it?
- Pass: the buyer can ask for the right help, and your team would get enough detail to act.
- Fix first: cut fields nobody uses and keep the ones sales needs. A shorter form is not better if your team has to call back just to learn what the buyer wanted.
Whether the message actually lands in the right inbox is a technical check. That belongs in your website relaunch checklist, run with your team's OK and a clearly labeled test.
How to Score It
Mark each test pass, unsure, or fail. Write down the exact spot where the tester got stuck. Put one person's name next to each fix.
| Test | What to write down |
|---|---|
| 1. Who you sell to | What the tester thought you do, in their words |
| 2. Product and limits | Where they looked for specs, and what they found |
| 3. Proof that fits | What the proof showed them, and what it left out |
| 4. Right place or person | Where the path ended, and whether it was correct |
| 5. Ask for help | Which field or step slowed them down |
Fix the failure closest to a lost quote or a wasted trip first. Then give the same job to a new tester. Someone who has already seen the site will not get stuck in the same place twice.
Five tests will show you a good first fix. They do not replace checks for accessibility, security, or a technical launch.
What a Connected Path Looks Like
The five tests work together. A product page can pass Test 2 and still send the buyer to a form that drops the product name, or to an inbox no rep reads. Walk the same made-up job from the first page all the way to the person who would answer it.
For the Sierra Pacific Windows Select Remodeler Program, Grit Blueprint built the program website, a contractor lead hub, sales materials, and in-person contractor training in Utah and Colorado. The Select Remodeler Program story shows how those pieces were planned to fit together. It shows the work that was done. It is not a score from these five tests, so run them on your own site.
What to Do After You Fix the First Problem
Before you pay to bring more people to the site, make sure the buyers you already get can finish the job. Once they can, the next question is how new buyers find you and why they pick you. That is the subject of what to do after your new website launches.
Questions and Answers
Give a phone to someone who did not build the site and hand them one made-up job, such as finding an exterior door and asking for a quote. Do not explain the menu. Watch where they stop, and write down that exact spot.
Pick someone who looks like a real buyer, such as a newer counter employee or a friend who builds or remodels. Avoid your web person and your sales manager, because they already know where everything is and will not get stuck where a buyer does.
Not to your sales team without warning. Have the tester walk through the form up to the send button to check the buyer's side. Checking that messages reach the right inbox is a separate technical check, done with your team's OK and a clearly labeled test.
Fix the failure closest to a lost quote or a wasted trip, such as a dead end on the way to a dealer or a form that drops the product the buyer was viewing. Then give the same job to a new tester to see if the fix worked.
No. They show whether a buyer can use the site. They do not check accessibility, security, redirects, search settings, or whether form messages are delivered. Run those checks too, especially before and after a website relaunch.
Want Help Putting It to Work?
A free call with Stefanie Couch. About 30 minutes.
Not ready to talk? Get the Built to Win Newsletter


