Book a Strategy Call Book a Strategy Call

Should You Hire a Marketer or an Agency?

Hire a marketer when the work is daily and has to happen inside your building. Hire an outside team when the work takes many skills at once, like a new website with photos and film. You can also do both.

A free call with Stefanie Couch. About 30 minutes.

A Marketer on Your Team Fits When

  • There is marketing work to do every day.
  • Someone needs to be in the building, close to your people and your customers.
  • You already have a plan, a brand, and a website that work.
Or

An Outside Team Fits When

  • The job takes many skills at once.
  • The job has a start and an end, like a website, a brand, or a shoot.
  • You want people who already know building products.

By Stefanie Couch, Founder & CEO of Grit Blueprint. Published .

A building company should hire an in house marketer for daily work that has to happen inside the building, and an outside team for jobs that take many skills at once or have an end. Some companies use both.

We are an outside team, so we have a side in this. We have tried to write the other side fairly. Some of the work below is better done by someone on your payroll, and we say so.

What Is the Work?

Before you post a job or sign a contract, list the work. Marketing work for a building company comes in four kinds, and each one asks for different skills.

The WorkOne In House MarketerAn Outside Team
StrategyWho to sell to, what to say, and where to show up. Knows your company from the inside. Can be too busy with daily work to step back from it. Has seen how other companies do it. Has to learn yours first.
WebsiteThe plan, the words, the design, the photos, the product details, and the build. Can run the project and keep the site up to date afterward. Doing every part alone is a lot to ask of one person. Has a planner, a writer, a designer, and a builder. Leaves when the site launches, unless you plan for upkeep.
Photos and filmA camera crew, sound, lights, and editing. Can take everyday photos as things happen. A full shoot and edit is a different job. Brings a crew and editors for the shoot. Is not there the day something worth filming happens, unless it was planned.
Ongoing contentPosts, articles, emails, and video, week after week. Is there every day, hears the stories first, and can post the same hour. Keeps a steady schedule with writers, designers, and editors. Needs someone inside to pass along what is happening and approve the work.

When Does an In House Hire Fit?

An in house marketer is the right call when the work never stops and needs someone who is there. Think of customer events and counter days, signs and flyers, emails to customers, and keeping the hours, people, and products right on the website.

Two Cofer Brothers team members in red Count on Cofer shirts help a customer at the store counter
The counter at Cofer Brothers, from our shoot. Daily work happens here, and it helps to have someone close to it.

That person also becomes the one who knows what is going on. Even if you hire an agency, someone inside has to answer its questions and approve its work.

Read your job post before you publish it. If it asks one person to plan the strategy, design the brand, build the website, shoot the video, and write every post, it describes a whole team.

When Does an Outside Team Fit?

An outside team fits when the job is bigger than one person, or when it has an end.

A new website is the clearest case. It takes a plan, words, design, photos, product details, and a build. Then it launches, and most of that work stops.

HarLand Windows & Doors in Roswell, Georgia, sells the product and does the install. We set the plan first. Then came the new brand, the website, and the showroom photos. We stay on as their content partner.

A wood pivot door opening into a sunroom in the HarLand Windows & Doors showroom
The HarLand Windows & Doors showroom in Roswell, Georgia, from our shoot.

An outside team also fits when you want people who already know the industry.

“They bring the expertise most family-owned businesses cannot access on their own.”

Scotty Harris, VP of Sales & Part Owner, Harris Door & Millwork

The work can be ongoing too. For TLC Elite, a building materials dealer in Dawsonville, Georgia, we run the marketing across social media, email, blogs, and search. We have done more than 26 shoots there. See Ongoing Content Packages.

“Cofer Brothers has been working with Stefanie and the Grit Blueprint team for over a year, and we plan to stay engaged.”

Jacob Irvine, Outside Sales Consultant, Cofer Brothers

An outside team can’t be in your building every day. If nobody inside owns the work, questions sit and approvals stall.

Can You Do Both?

Yes. We work beside in house marketing people. We agree on where you need help and which jobs your team already handles. That includes who supplies information, who reviews the work, and who publishes it.

One way to split it is by the kind of work. Your marketer owns the daily work and knows what is happening. The outside team does the big builds and the shoots, and keeps finished content coming.

One person who has worked with us runs marketing inside a lumber company.

“I LOVED working with the Grit Blueprint team! They are so amazing and easy to work with.”

Ashley Guest, Marketing Manager, Harbin Lumber

What About the Money?

This guide leaves out salaries and prices on purpose. Salaries change by market and prices change by job, so a number here would be a guess.

Compare the two by the work first. Once you know what work you need, get a real number for each choice from the people who would do it.

Five Questions to Settle First

  • What marketing work do we need done in the next year?
  • Which of it has an end, and which never stops?
  • What skills does each piece take?
  • Who inside our company will answer questions and approve the work?
  • Who needs to be in the building, and how often?

If most of your list is daily work, start with a hire. If most of it is a few big jobs, start with an outside team. If it is both, split it.

Leaning toward an agency? Read How to Choose a Building Materials Marketing Agency.

More Guides

Stefanie Couch, Founder and CEO of Grit Blueprint, in a navy pinstripe blazer and pink hat, seated and smiling at the camera

Not Sure Which Way to Go?

Stefanie Couch, Founder & CEO

Bring your list of work to the call. We’ll talk through where you need help and which jobs your team already handles.

A free call with Stefanie Couch. About 30 minutes.