To compare marketing or media proposals for a building products company, check five things in writing. Does it name the buyer and the job the work must do? Is the scope concrete? Who checks product claims? What rights do you get to the finished work? What happens after delivery? A polished reel can start the talk. It cannot answer those five questions for you.
This article is for the stage after the first meetings, when two or three proposals are on your desk. If you are still building a shortlist, start with How to Choose a Building Materials Marketing Agency. It covers the six questions to ask in the first meeting. This article covers what to look for in the paper that comes back.
Send Every Provider the Same Real Problem
Proposals are hard to compare when each one answers a different question. Give every provider the same sales problem before they write.
For example: "Our reps keep explaining why this door system fits some openings but not others. What would you make, what facts would you need from us, and how would a rep use it?"
Now you can read the proposals side by side. You are comparing answers to one question instead of three lists of services.
Does the Proposal Name the Buyer and the Next Step?
A manufacturer, a distributor, and a dealer can sell the same product and still need different marketing. Look for who the work is for and what that person decides next. An architect may need a current drawing and a technical contact. A dealer may need ordering and support details. A homeowner may need to find a showroom that carries the line.
Be careful with a proposal that jumps straight to a platform or a filming style and never names the buyer.
Is the Scope Concrete Enough to Check?
"Monthly content" could mean almost anything. The proposal should tell you:
- which formats are included, and how many
- what counts as a revision, and how many rounds you get
- who writes the copy, and who supplies the facts
- what is left out on purpose
- what your team has to do, and by when
For a shoot, ask how the crew gets ready. A plant shoot needs access, safe places to film, and an expert who can explain what the camera sees. A jobsite may need permission from several parties. A trade show is loud and busy, and your booth team has little time. Ask what happens if a needed shot is not possible that day. Will the team change the plan, come back, or use another source? Get the answer in writing before the shoot.
Grit Blueprint agrees on the shoot, the finished pieces, and how you plan to use them before filming. Scope and price are agreed before any work starts. Hold us to the same test you give anyone else.
Who Checks the Product Claims?
Building products carry ratings, sizes, warranties, and code details. One wrong line can cost a sale or cause a problem on the job. The proposal should name how facts get checked and who on your side signs off.
Also look at how the provider talks about its own past work. A live site shows that a site exists. A finished video shows what was made. A claim about sales growth needs more evidence than either one. Nobody should promise that a format will bring rankings, AI mentions, or a set number of leads.
What Rights Do You Get to the Finished Work?
Ask what you may do with the work, and for how long. Can your reps share it? Can dealers use it? Can it run in ads? Do you get the raw or editable files?
Ask who handles permissions for music, photos, locations, and people on camera. A customer's logo in a case study does not mean you can use that customer's footage everywhere. Have the right person read the actual terms. If your plan depends on a right, put it in the agreement.
What Happens After Delivery?
A rep should not have to dig through a folder of files named "final final" to find the right video. Ask how files will be named, sorted, and handed over. Who makes a version that is ready to share? Who posts it, if posting is in scope? Who updates it when the product changes?
For monthly work, ask how the next topic gets picked. A good answer ties together buyer questions, what you already have, input from your team, and what the last round showed. Ask what the provider would stop doing if a piece did not help.
Score Each Proposal
Give each area a 0, 1 or 2. Zero means the proposal does not answer it. One means it is described. Two means it is backed by a real example or a clear written commitment. The score helps you decide. It is not a tested measure of quality.
| Area | What to look for | Score |
|---|---|---|
| Buyer | Names the buyer, the question, and the next step for your problem | ___ |
| Proof | Shows related work and does not stretch what it proves | ___ |
| Scope | Lists outputs, revisions, exclusions, and your team's part | ___ |
| Fact check | Says how product claims get checked and by whom | ___ |
| Rights | Terms cover how you plan to use the work | ___ |
| Handoff | Shows how your team will find and use the files | ___ |
| Next round | Explains how results change the next piece of work | ___ |
Treat rights, access, and the fact check as must-haves. A high total does not make up for a missing right to use the work where you need it.
A Made-Up Example: Two Proposals for a Plant Video
Proposal A offers a film day and a finished overview video. It does not say who the video is for, who approves it, or how sales will use it.
Proposal B asks which buyer concern the plant footage must answer. It includes a prep call with the plant expert, an agreed shot list, a check of product claims, and the file formats the sales team asked for.
B gives you more to go on. A may still be a good provider, so send it the same questions and let it revise. Then compare the revised scope and price side by side. If a shoot is the work you are buying, you can also see how Grit Blueprint plans photo and video shoots at plants, yards, and jobsites.
After this, you should be able to explain what will be made, why a buyer needs it, what your team must do, and how the handoff will work. If the work will be shared with your own staff, use the ownership card for splitting jobs with a partner.
Questions and Answers
Send every provider the same real sales problem first. Then check each proposal in writing for five things: the buyer and next step, a concrete scope, who checks product claims, what rights you get to the work, and what happens after delivery. Score each area 0, 1 or 2.
It should list which formats are included and how many, what counts as a revision and how many rounds you get, who writes and who supplies facts, what is left out on purpose, and what your team has to do and by when. Monthly content with no detail is hard to check.
Ask whether reps and dealers can share the work, whether it can run in ads, how long you may use it, and whether you get raw or editable files. Ask who handles permissions for music, locations, and people on camera. Put any right your plan depends on into the agreement.
Give each area a 0, 1 or 2: buyer, proof, scope, fact check, rights, handoff, and next round. Zero means the proposal does not answer it, one means it is described, and two means it is backed by an example or a written commitment. Treat rights, access, and the fact check as must-haves.
Send it the same questions you sent everyone else and let the provider revise. Then compare the revised scope and price side by side. A provider may have answered a different question than you meant, so give every provider the same real sales problem before you judge.
Want Help Putting It to Work?
A free call with Stefanie Couch. About 30 minutes.
Not ready to talk? Get the Built to Win Newsletter


